HARRISMITH – Proposed national animal identification rules have raised concerns among livestock farmers about cost, access and how they will be enforced.
Maluti-a-Phofung farmer Alison Oates said the requirements are too demanding and do not consider the realities of rural animal owners.
“The vast majority of animals owned in South Africa are owned by people who really don’t have reliable internet access and are living a fairly subsistence lifestyle.”
She questioned how rules for domestic animals like dogs, including compulsory microchipping, would be enforced among owners who cannot afford it.
“The idea that all dogs, for example, will be microchipped is frankly absurd.”
Oates also questioned the need to report certain matters to police, saying it already takes hours to get served.
She said existing livestock branding records are not always well kept, raising doubts about government’s capacity to run an even bigger system.
She believes participation should start as voluntary, with financial incentives. If feedlots and butchers pay more for properly identified animals, farmers would have a reason to comply.
Harrismith farmer Albert Potgieter, who has farmed for over 30 years, said ear tags already help farmers track fertility, productivity and breeding. Tags help identify cows that calve regularly and early, and those that should be culled.
Keeping unproductive cattle is expensive. Potgieter said one cow can cost R2 000 to R3 000 a year to keep. If she does not calve regularly, that can cost R6 000 or more over two years.
Farmers also compare a cow’s weight with her calf’s weight at weaning to judge if she is productive.
*What the proposed rules seek to do*
The Department of Agriculture published the proposed Regulations Relating to Identification of Animals in Government Gazette 55507 on 6 October 2026, under the Animal Improvement Act of 1998.
The rules aim to strengthen identification, ownership records and traceability through identification devices, registration, record-keeping, and rules on animal movements and changes in ownership.
Agriculture Minister Willie Aucamp has said the regulations are out for public comment and are not yet in force.
The 90-day consultation period allows farmers and other stakeholders to raise concerns before the rules are finalised.