VAR announcement sparks debate

By Mahlasinyane Motsoeneng

QWAQWA – The announcement by Sports, Arts, and Recreation Minister Gayton Mackenzie to introduce Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology to South African football in the 2025/2026 financial year has sparked intense debate among fans, experts, and stakeholders.

Despite concerns over costs and the league’s readiness, Mackenzie remains committed to implementing VAR, addressing long-standing calls from fans frustrated with inconsistent refereeing decisions.

Among the supporters of VAR is Bloemfontein Celtic’s top fan, Botha Msila, who believes the technology will bring much-needed accuracy to officiating.

“VAR will help reduce human errors made by referees, which have cost many clubs dearly in the past,” Msila stated. “We’ve been waiting for this, and it’s essential for improving the quality of football.”

However, not everyone shares Msila’s optimism. Football commentator Tladi Moloi argues that South Africa is not yet equipped to handle VAR effectively.

“The country, fans, and Premier Soccer League (PSL) management are not fully prepared to implement and operate VAR,” Moloi said.

“Only the minister seems to be pushing for it, but proper planning and consideration of costs, labor, and consequences are crucial.”

Moloi suggested that South Africa should first adopt Goal Line Technology, following the successful model used in European leagues. He also raised concerns about the security of VAR equipment, given the current ownership structure of football fields in the country.

Football commentator and journalist Tladi Moloi.

On the other hand, Letlatsa Moloi, coach of the Samba Boys, remains optimistic about VAR’s potential to improve the game and create employment opportunities.

“VAR will help reduce bribery and promote fair play,” Letlatsa remarked.

“It will also create jobs for operators and enhance the overall standard of football in the country.”

As the debate over VAR’s introduction continues, one thing is certain: the technology has the potential to reshape South African football, for better or worse.